Skip to content

Valentine’s Day Piñata Cake

  Rating 0.0

Prep

25 mins

Bake

1 hour 35 mins

Serves

10+

Difficulty

Hard

About

Surprise your loved ones with a delightful Piñata cake for Valentine’s Day. Filled with chocolate hearts or it could be with their favourite sweet treats.

made using

Pure Cane Caster Sugar

View product 
Share this recipe
Instructions
Ingredients
Reviews
Step 1

Preheat the oven to 180C.

Step 2

Grease and line the bases of 4 20cm cake tins with baking paper.

Step 3

Cream the sugar and butter together until pale and fluffy. Gradually add in the eggs, combining well after each addition. Sift in the flour and baking powder and mix until well combined.

Step 4

Divide the cake mixture equally between the cake tins.

Step 5

Bake for 30–35 minutes until well risen and golden brown on top.

Step 6

Cool on a wire rack and start preparing your buttercream by beating the butter for 5 minutes. Slowly sift in the icing sugar, mixing well with each addition, followed by the milk.

Step 7

Transfer a quarter of the buttercream to a separate bowl, add a drop of the red food colouring and mix until an even pink colour is achieved throughout.

Step 8

When the cakes are completely cool, trim any domed tops from the cakes so that they are completely flat. Cut a 8–9cm round hole in the centre of 3 of the cakes using a glass, bowl or pastry cutter.

Step 9

Build the piñata cake by placing one cake with a hole in it on a cake stand or board. Spread over a layer of white buttercream and jam. Repeat the process with the next 2 cakes with holes in them.

Step 10

Fill the cavity with the chocolate hearts and place the final layer of cake on top.

Step 11

Using a large palette knife, spread a thin layer of the white buttercream all over the sides and top of the cake.

Step 12

Chill the cake for 15–20 minutes before decorating with small swirls of pink buttercream.

Ingredients – 5 items

Serving

1

For the sponge

Pure Cane Caster Sugar

Tate & Lyle Fairtrade Pure Cane Caster Sugar

500 g
Butter

Butter

softened

500 g
Eggs

Eggs

beaten

9
Flour

Self raising flour

500 g
Baking-powder

Baking powder

2 tsp

For the buttercream

Butter

Unsalted butter, softened

280 g
Fairtrade Cane Icing Sugar

Tate & Lyle Pure Cane Icing Sugar

sifted

550 g
Milk

Milk

1.5 tbsp
Food-colouring-liquid

Red food colouring

For the filling

Raspberry-jam

Jam

200 g
Chocolate

Chocolate

heart shaped

400 g

Rate this recipe!

Share your thoughts or advice

Good job, now enjoy!

Don't forget to share your creation using our hashtags in the chance to get featured.

#TATE&LYLESUGAR #WELOVEBAKING
Brownies this good don’t happen by chance.
They’re the result of expert baking, quality ingredients, and a little Tate & Lyle magic.
@comptoir_bakery knows what they’re doing – and we’re proud to be part of it.

#TrustedByTheBest
Put a sunshine spin on a classic with these Pimm’s Cream Scones ☀️🍓 

A fun twist on the traditional bake, this recipe combines the timeless charm of scones with the fruity, refreshing flavour of a summer favourite - Pimm’s! Made with Tate & Lyle Golden Caster Sugar, they’re perfect for garden parties, afternoon teas, or just because.

Find the recipe via link in our bio.

#TateAndLyleSugars #SummerBakes #Pimms #AfternoonTeaUpgrade
🍪 One cookie to rule them all…
During the visit to Comptoir, we came across a giant cookie that stopped us in our tracks. Think golden edges, gooey centre, and serious snack envy.

#trustedbythebest
Light-as-air cream, golden pastry layers, and a dusting of sweetness – no wonder @comptoir_bakery trust Tate & Lyle Sugars to bring their bakes to life.
Matty certainly approves 👀

#TrustedByTheBest
Cool down in style with a homemade Vanilla Matcha Frappe. Made with Tate & Lyle Vanilla Flavoured Syrup for that perfect balance of creamy sweetness, and topped with a swirl of indulgent squirty cream - it’s the ultimate café-style treat you can make at home. 

Just blend, pour, and sip!💚✨

Find a variety of recipes via link in our bio.

#TateAndLyleSugars #Matcha #FrappeFix #MatchaMoments
Trusted by the Best – Comptoir Bakery 🥐

We’re kicking things off at the incredible @comptoir_bakery - a French-style bakery in the heart of London - where @mattyedgell steps into the kitchen to meet the team, get hands-on with their signature bakes, and discover why they trust Tate & Lyle Sugars to bring the magic to every bake.

From buttery, flaky croissant dough to their iconic pistachio brioche Brionut, everything they create is a labour of love - and sugar is at the heart of it. ✨
This is just the start of our journey to meet the brilliant bakers who put their trust in Tate & Lyle Sugars.

📍 First stop: Comptoir Bakery. Let’s go.

#tateandlyle #trustedbythebest
Want to bake something special for Dad this Father’s Day? 🧁 

These easy triple chocolate cupcakes are rich, chocolatey, and packed with flavour - made even better with the warm, caramel notes of Tate & Lyle Golden Caster Sugar.

A simple, homemade treat that’s guaranteed to make him smile!

Find the recipe via link in our bio.🍫

#TateAndLyleSugars #WeLoveBaking #FathersDay #Cupcakes #Baking

Our Products

View all products