
Prep
25 minsBake
1 hour 35 minsServes
10+Difficulty
Hard
About
Surprise your loved ones with a delightful Piñata cake for Valentine’s Day. Filled with chocolate hearts or it could be with their favourite sweet treats.

Preheat the oven to 180C.
Grease and line the bases of 4 20cm cake tins with baking paper.
Cream the sugar and butter together until pale and fluffy. Gradually add in the eggs, combining well after each addition. Sift in the flour and baking powder and mix until well combined.
Divide the cake mixture equally between the cake tins.
Bake for 30–35 minutes until well risen and golden brown on top.
Cool on a wire rack and start preparing your buttercream by beating the butter for 5 minutes. Slowly sift in the icing sugar, mixing well with each addition, followed by the milk.
Transfer a quarter of the buttercream to a separate bowl, add a drop of the red food colouring and mix until an even pink colour is achieved throughout.
When the cakes are completely cool, trim any domed tops from the cakes so that they are completely flat. Cut a 8–9cm round hole in the centre of 3 of the cakes using a glass, bowl or pastry cutter.
Build the piñata cake by placing one cake with a hole in it on a cake stand or board. Spread over a layer of white buttercream and jam. Repeat the process with the next 2 cakes with holes in them.
Fill the cavity with the chocolate hearts and place the final layer of cake on top.
Using a large palette knife, spread a thin layer of the white buttercream all over the sides and top of the cake.
Chill the cake for 15–20 minutes before decorating with small swirls of pink buttercream.
Ingredients – 5 items
1
For the sponge

Tate & Lyle Fairtrade Pure Cane Caster Sugar

Butter
softened

Eggs
beaten

Self raising flour

Baking powder
For the buttercream

Unsalted butter, softened

Tate & Lyle Pure Cane Icing Sugar
sifted

Milk

Red food colouring
For the filling

Jam

Chocolate
heart shaped
Rate this recipe!
Share your thoughts or advice
Good job, now enjoy!
Don't forget to share your creation using our hashtags in the chance to get featured.
Nothing says summer like a classic Eton Mess ☀️🍓 Made with Tate & Lyle Pure Cane Caster Sugar it’s light, creamy, and bursting with fresh berries! This easy recipe is a guaranteed crowd-pleaser, the perfect balance of sweetness and crunch in every spoonful.
Ready to whip one up? Find the recipe via link in our bio.
#TateAndLyleSugars #SummerDeserts #EtonMess #EasyBakes

Started in a home kitchen. Now it’s one of the most talked-about bakeries in London.
Greedy Cow’s Korean Milk Doughnut is more than just a viral treat – it’s part of a bigger journey built on graft, great ideas, and serious baking talent.
Proud to feature Greedy Cow in the latest Trusted by the Best series.
#TrustedByTheBest
Part of Trusted by the Best, promoting chosen Tate & Lyle customer bakeries.
#advert | T&Cs in bio

Whisking up some hot takes 🔥
What’s the secret to great baking? And if your bake was a celeb… who’d it be?
Matty & Quentin from Comptoir spill all in this rapid-fire Q&A.
Part of Trusted by the Best, promoting chosen Tate & Lyle customer bakeries.
#advert | T&Cs in bio
Tate & Lyle is a British brand that has been refining sugar of EU and non-EU origin since 1859.

Ice cream isn’t just for cones! 🍦✨
Take your favourite flavours to the next level - think gooey ice cream sandwiches, creamy milkshakes, or even layered into a show-stopping ice cream cake! However you scoop it, there’s no wrong way to enjoy a little frozen fun.
Find some inspo via link in our bio.
#TateAndLyleSugars #SummerTreats #IceCreamYourWay

Put a sunshine spin on a classic with these Pimm’s Cream Scones ☀️🍓
A fun twist on the traditional bake, this recipe combines the timeless charm of scones with the fruity, refreshing flavour of a summer favourite - Pimm’s! Made with Tate & Lyle Golden Caster Sugar, they’re perfect for garden parties, afternoon teas, or just because.
Find the recipe via link in our bio.
#TateAndLyleSugars #SummerBakes #Pimms #AfternoonTeaUpgrade

Our Products
View all products