Skip to content

Lemon Custard Pie

  Rating 5.0

Prep

30 mins

Bake

1hr

Serves

8

Difficulty

Medium

About

When life gives you lemons... make lemon custard pie! This velvety smooth and super creamy lemon pie never fails to impress! It's made using our Tate & Lyle Cane Caster Sugar, which is the best for these sorts of bakes as it dissolves quickly and doesn't leave any grainy texture (hello super-smooth filling!). The fresh, lemony flavour of the custard filling and the sweet, flaky, buttery pastry are a match made in heaven!

made using

Golden Caster

View product 
Share this recipe
Instructions
Ingredients
Reviews
Step 1

On a lightly floured surface, roll out the pastry to the thickness of a pound coin, then lift into a 23 cm tart tin. Press gently on the sides and the bottom of the tin, then trim off any excess pastry.

Step 2

Using a fork, gently prick few holes in the pastry and transfer it to the fridge for about 25 minutes.

Step 3

In the meantime, prepare the filling. Mix all the ingredients together apart from lemon zest. Sieve the mixture and add the lemon zest. Set aside.

Step 4

Heat the oven to 140 C (fan). Line the tart tin with baking parchment or foil and fill it in with rice or ceramic baking beans. Blind bake for 10 minutes, then remove the foil/ parchment and bake for another 20 minutes until pale golden.

Step 5

Remove it from the oven, pour in the lemon and egg mixture and bake for another 30 minutes until just set. Leave to cool, then remove from the tin.

Step 6

You can decorate the tart with some meringue kisses and sugar flowers if you would like. Enjoy!

Ingredients – 6 items

Serving

1

Block of shortcrust pastry

Sweet

375 g
Eggs

Large eggs

5
Fairtrade Golden Caster

Fairtrade Tate & Lyle Golden Caster Sugar

150 g
Cream

Double cream

150 ml
Lemon

Lemon

Juice and zest

2
Flowers-Edible

Decorative sugar flowers

Optional

2

Rate this recipe!

Share your thoughts or advice

Recipe reviews

One review

Good job, now enjoy!

Don't forget to share your creation using our hashtags in the chance to get featured.

#TATE&LYLESUGAR #WELOVEBAKING
Big ideas. Bold flavours. Brunch, redefined.

@milkcoffeeldn tells us what drives them in this #TrustedByTheBest Q&A.

#TrustedByTheBest 

Part of Trusted by the Best, promoting chosen Tate & Lyle customer bakeries.
#advert | T&Cs in bio
Treat yourself to café-style comfort at home with a Salted Caramel Latte ☕✨ 

Made with Tate & Lyle Salted Caramel Flavour Beverage Syrup, it’s the perfect blend of rich, buttery sweetness and a touch of salt - pure autumn bliss in a cup 🍂💛

Shop your bottle directly from sugarandsyrup.com or Amazon (links in bio!).

#SaltedCaramelSeason #TateAndLyleSyrups
Nostalgia, remixed. 🍌

Banana bread taken to new heights with halva butter & pumpkin seed tahini — Milk’s way of turning comfort food into something extraordinary.

#TrustedByTheBest 

Part of Trusted by the Best, promoting chosen Tate & Lyle customer bakeries.�#advert | T&Cs in bio
Sweet. Tangy. Unforgettable. 🍓✨

@milkcoffeeldn craft their sumac-spiced jam with Tate & Lyle Jam Sugar, turning a classic into something extraordinary.

#TrustedByTheBest 

Part of Trusted by the Best, promoting chosen Tate & Lyle customer bakeries.
#advert | T&Cs in bio
Add a little sparkle to your Bonfire Night with this Orange, Lime & Chilli Marmalade 🔥🍊 

Made with Tate & Lyle Preserving Sugar, it’s zesty, sweet, and just the right amount of fiery - perfect for spreading on toast while you watch the fireworks light up the sky 🎆✨

Get the recipe via link in our bio.
#TateAndLylePreserves #SweetAndSpicy #HomemadeMarmalade
Layers of dedication. Milk shows us how quality and creativity can transform the everyday into the extraordinary.

#TrustedByTheBest 

Part of Trusted by the Best, promoting chosen Tate & Lyle customer bakeries.�#advert | T&Cs in bio
Halloween is this week, so why not bake up a spooky treat? 🎃👻 

These Vegan Halloween Brownies are rich, fudgy, and oh-so-chocolatey 🍫 Made with Tate & Lyle Pure Cane Granulated Sugar for the perfect sweetness, they’re guaranteed to be a hit with every little (and big!) monster around.

Find the recipe via link in our bio.

#HalloweenBakes #VeganBrownies
From Balham to brunch brilliance ✨

@milkcoffeeldn has been redefining mornings since 2012, serving creativity, nostalgia and quality on every plate. Discover how passion and independent suppliers keep them at the top of their game.

#TrustedByTheBest 

Part of Trusted by the Best, promoting chosen Tate & Lyle customer bakeries.
#advert | T&Cs in bio

Our Products

View all products